Well being Issues is a month-to-month column that options skilled recommendation from medical doctors and medical specialists in Singapore. Have a burning well being query? E mail us at magherworld@sph.com.sg with “Well being Issues” in your topic header and we’ll get again to you.
What’s the distinction between radiotherapy versus chemotherapy? In case your information of medical jargon is (like us) rudimentary at most, then it’s a query that will stump you. In truth, a fast survey of our Her World workforce revealed that we had been equally – for the dearth of a greater phrase – clueless about these remedies.
“Radiation remedy makes use of excessive vitality x-rays to soundly deal with and handle most cancers by destroying most cancers cells, thus lowering the expansion and unfold of most cancers,” explains Dr Choo Bok Ai, a senior radiation oncologist in non-public follow in Singapore.
However, chemotherapy makes use of highly effective, anti-cancer chemical substances/medication to kill the fast-growing most cancers cells in your physique.
He provides: “Radiation remedy assaults most cancers cells whereas limiting harm to wholesome cells, as most cancers cells are extra delicate to radiation.”
However what concerning the efficacy of radiotherapy vs chemotherapy? Are there situations the place one remedy is best than the opposite? In accordance with Dr Choo, these remedies usually are not mutually unique. For instance, “radiation may be given alone or together with chemotherapy.”
“Relying on the most cancers profile, chemotherapy can improve the impact and influence of radiation remedy by 9% to 26% when given collectively, for instance, within the remedy of lung, oesophagus, head and neck and cervix most cancers. Chemotherapy by itself is utilized in Stage 4 cancers when the most cancers has unfold extensively or as a further remedy after surgical procedure to forestall a recurrence within the physique.
“As compared, radiation is used to forestall native recurrence after surgical procedure. For instance, radiation is given after a lumpectomy, which is partial elimination of breast tissue, to ensure that the affected person to keep away from a mastectomy, which is elimination of the entire breast. Utilizing radiation after a lumpectomy helps to protect the breast from pointless elimination with the identical management fee for the most cancers,” he says.
Beneath, he elaborates on the newest developments, in addition to the widespread issues and misconceptions concerning the remedy.
Inform us extra concerning the newest developments in radiotherapy.
Radiotherapy has advanced to grow to be far more exact than one to 20 years in the past. New applied sciences resembling machine studying and AI enable us to tailor remedy plans to the person. We are able to even replace radiologists within the remedy room if there are modifications to the affected person’s physiology.
Stereotactic radiosurgery for mind tumours resembling HyperArc has superior considerably. These options enable medical doctors to deal with as much as 20 tumours inside a couple of minutes, with every most cancers being focused individually This not solely gives a faster remedy for the affected person but in addition much less uncomfortable side effects.
Beforehand, these many tumours would have required entire mind radiation which comes with vital cognitive uncomfortable side effects.
It’s stated that radiation remedy has fewer uncomfortable side effects than chemotherapy. Is that this true?
The uncomfortable side effects from radiation remedy differ barely from chemotherapy.
As radiation remedy is focused to a particular space of the physique, sufferers usually expertise uncomfortable side effects at that individual space. For instance, for head and neck cancers, the uncomfortable side effects can be restricted solely to the pinnacle and neck space.
Irritation on pores and skin: Widespread early uncomfortable side effects skilled throughout radiation remedy happen because of irritation. For instance, the pores and skin can grow to be crimson and dry and sometimes peel. These pores and skin reactions will normally resolve just a few weeks after remedy has completed.
Feeling drained: Fatigue is one other widespread facet impact and a affected person can even expertise this facet impact from chemotherapy. The quantity of fatigue will differ for every particular person and doesn’t normally have an effect on the affected person’s each day actions significantly.
Hair loss: It is a widespread facet impact from chemotherapy. Nonetheless for radiation remedy, hair loss might happen if the focused space is the pinnacle space. The hair can develop again in time.
A lot of the uncomfortable side effects from radiation remedy happen whereas the remedy is in progress and can resolve fairly rapidly after the remedy ends.
What’s the remedy cycle like for radiation remedy sufferers?
Therapy is normally supplied every day (Monday to Friday) over quite a few weeks, which permits the radiation to focus on most cancers cells and gives wholesome cells with sufficient time to get better over the weekend. The course of radiation remedy is exclusive and tailor-made for every particular person, relying on the placement and stage of illness, kind of most cancers, age and common well being.
The same old radiation remedy schedule for breast most cancers after surgical procedure is 2 weeks for early breast most cancers and three to 4 weeks for extra superior phases.
When no surgical procedure is carried out and the stage of most cancers is extra superior, for instance, in head and neck cancers, lung or prostate, the size of a course of radiation may be over six to seven weeks.
What are the widespread issues about radiation remedy?
For head and neck most cancers, widespread uncomfortable side effects of radiation are pores and skin burn, mouth ulcers or a sore throat affecting the power to eat. All sufferers do get a sure diploma of those uncomfortable side effects however extreme results resulting in hospital admission for hydration or insertion of a feeding tube is uncommon.
That is actually totally different in comparison with radiation accomplished 20 years in the past, when most sufferers would have required a feeding tube. With development within the {hardware} and software program used to ship radiation, the radiation dose may be adjusted to keep away from excessive doses to the oral cavity, throat and salivary glands. Most sufferers’ signs enhance inside one to 2 weeks upon completion of remedy and are nicely managed with a comfortable eating regimen, oral mouthwash and ache killers.
In breast most cancers, the uncomfortable side effects are a lot much less with solely pores and skin redness as the commonest concern. These days, the radiation dose may be adjusted in order that painful pores and skin peeling may be averted. Common moisturisers can be given to use through the radiation remedy to minimise the facet impact.
Dr Choo is a senior radiation oncologist in non-public follow with 20 years of expertise in most cancers remedy. He’s the present chairman of the Chapter of Radiation Oncology, Academy of Medication.
Supply: Her World
