I used to be not too long ago recruited to a different firm for a greater alternative. A associate at my former agency supplied to fulfill me close to my new job and take me to lunch as a token of gratitude for my work there; he additionally wished my headhunter contacts, as he’s seeking to make a transfer himself. Whereas we have been consuming, I discussed that almost all of my new group, together with my boss, are girls, and that each the dynamic and work-life steadiness have been higher than the previous agency. He responded with “This may occasionally sound sexist, however … ” and continued on to make a disparaging comment about girls.
My query: He’s hounding me for my headhunter contacts. I really feel I don’t owe him something, however are not looking for a confrontation. What ought to I do? — Identify Withheld
From the Ethicist:
The way in which folks study that their sexist attitudes are usually not solely flawed but additionally unwelcome is by being held accountable for expressing them. You don’t say that the comment was out of character on your former colleague. Notably should you suppose it was reflective of his worldview, you’d be serving to the reason for gender equality should you informed him that his sexist comment made you disinclined to advance his profession. Would the fee to you be too nice? Given that you simply’re in the identical line of enterprise, you may decide that alienating him is a nasty thought — possibly he’d attempt to injury your repute as payback on your calling him out.
Sadly, there’s no easy technique to keep away from his request with out inflicting offense. Ignoring him may merely immediate him to pester you additional, and your purpose is seemingly to get him out of your life, to not have him buzzing round you want a nettled wasp. You can give him what he needs so as to hold the peace, however that may gnaw at your conscience. Your closing choice is to supply him your contacts, whereas letting the headhunters know of your issues about him. In the event you achieve this, it is best to discover a technique to let your ex-colleague know, too, that you simply discovered his commentary unsettling.
A Bonus Query
In the course of the holidays, my associate’s teenage nephew got here out to me. I began courting his aunt earlier than he was born, so he’s household to me. I really like him dearly, and I attempted to be as supportive as I might. I’m the primary grownup he’s informed. He additionally informed me that he’s courting a boy from faculty.
Right here is the rub: His father’s habits concerning L.G.B.T.Q. folks is harmful, and the daddy has been violent up to now. He as soon as bodily attacked an individual he took for a drag queen whereas drunk, and his angle towards homosexual males is dreadful. My sister-in-law separated from him years in the past, however my nephew nonetheless spends half his time at his father’s home. So all I can consider is what occurs if this man comes house to his son making out with a boy, which my nephew tells me has nearly occurred no less than as soon as.
I do know I can’t betray my nephew’s belief and out him to his mother (who may be capable to intervene earlier than one thing occurs), however I actually don’t suppose he’s protected together with his dad. And he’s only a child. How do I inform a 14-year-old boy, already scared his household gained’t settle for him as a result of he’s homosexual, to not make out with the boy he likes as a result of his dad is usually a violent homophobe? — Identify Withheld
From the Ethicist:
This teenager is fortunate to have a loving grownup whom he trusts on his facet. However you clearly suppose he’d be higher off taking his mom into his confidence too. The very first thing to do is to assist your nephew suppose by whether or not he ought to inform her, particularly provided that it would assist mitigate the chance posed by his father’s anti-gay attitudes and habits. You can even volunteer to be there when he does come out to her, if he thinks that might be useful.
However no matter your nephew decides about this, you do must have a frank dialog with him about his father’s attitudes and alert him to your issues. Fourteen-year-old boys are usually not typically ready for all of the emotional ups and downs of past love, and he could also be inclined to take extra dangers than he ought to.
Readers Reply
The earlier column’s query was from a reader whose rich buddy had not too long ago confided she received school monetary support for her son by having the son’s stepmother lie and declare him as a depending on her taxes for a number of years. This buddy and her husband make a mixed revenue of over $500,000. Our letter author shared: “I simply discovered that her son is now getting a full grant to a really costly non-public school. I’m alleged to take a weekend journey with my buddy in a number of weeks, however I’m so offended about this I don’t know if I can communicate to her. Is that this fraud? What’s my accountability on this scenario?”
In his response, the Ethicist famous: “What your buddy is doing is critically flawed, and the indignation you’re feeling is a becoming response to it. You may have another excuse to be offended. In telling you this story, your buddy confirmed that she took you to be somebody who would share her indifference to the ethical points right here.” The Ethicist excused the letter author from an obligation to report the deception, however wrote: “You must no less than inform her that what she and her household are doing is abhorrent, in addition to illegal, and that they shouldn’t do it subsequent yr. … Your conniving buddy is principally taking part in Robin Hood in reverse. Possibly this isn’t a friendship price holding onto.” (Reread the total query and reply right here.)
⬥
This isn’t a no-harm-no-foul scenario; it’s theft of a substantial amount of cash, most likely tens of hundreds of {dollars}, that ought to have gone to a extra deserving pupil. Would the Ethicist advocate turning a blind eye and never reporting a buddy who had robbed a financial institution? In fact not. What’s the distinction? — Craig
⬥
I really like the Ethicist’s thought of confronting the buddy with the idea that she appears to suppose you’re the sort of one that would tolerate, and even admire, such fraud. You may have been insulted. In spite of everything these years, has she no thought who you might be and what your morals are? — Cliff
⬥
The son might not know the total story or perceive the implications of his dad and mom’ fraud as we’ve seen in current information tales. He’s the one who would endure most maybe from his dismissal from the varsity. That file may observe him all through his profession. What a horrible instance to set for a kid. — Pamela
⬥
As a substitute of the Ethicist’s euphemism of Robin Hood, can we acknowledge that is doubtless white collar crime? A theft of tens of hundreds of {dollars}? Admittedly there was no risk of violence and they’re from an economically advantaged demographic — each components within the disparities we see in arrests, convictions and sentences. I’m positive their actions mirror recommendation amongst a sure “sensible” crowd. The author is right: It’s despicable. — Robert
⬥
Many years in the past, I used to be a type of children in monetary want who obtained a full scholarship for all 4 years. I think about that present the muse of the individual I’ve since change into. School was my first expertise of being supported intellectually and cheered on. This household has stolen extra than simply cash. — Wandajune
Supply: NY Times
